ESG and Mounted-Revenue Indices Surge in 2020


Market indices have seen fixed evolution in additional than a century of historical past, however by no means extra so than within the final yr.

On 3 July 1884, the world’s first inventory index, the Dow Jones Transportation Index, was printed by Charles Dow. And yearly since then, market indices have advanced and grown in scale and scope to fulfill the increasing wants of buyers. Expertise and higher sourcing of enter costs and knowledge have led to rather more correct methods to replicate markets and subsectors. And that has by no means been extra true than in 2020.

Subscribe Button

Indices had been first used solely to measure markets. Extra not too long ago, their functions have broadened they usually have come to function the premise for a variety of funding merchandise. Innovation continues to drive their expanded use.

Whereas indices comprise a well-established business spanning 136 years, the 2020 benchmark survey from the Index Trade Affiliation (IIA) exhibits a sector unafraid of constructive transformation. It demonstrates IIA members responded shortly to vary, to the compression and uncertainty which have marked this yr’s markets and investor preferences.

How have they accomplished this? By growing new forms of indices, significantly in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) and stuck revenue. Certainly, survey knowledge exhibits index suppliers are competing and innovating most quickly in these two areas, providing new sophistication for buyers in a market that calls for it.

Eye-Opening Outcomes

So what’s the Index Trade Affiliation and what’s the objective of our benchmark survey?

Based in 2012, the IIA represents the worldwide index business by working with market contributors, regulators, and different key stakeholders to advertise sound practices within the sector whereas serving buyers. Our main focus is selling index business greatest practices and speaking the worth of market indices to the general public. Our survey is an annual “report card” of kinds for our sector. It’s how we measure the whole variety of indices and establish notable developments over the previous yr and past. Previous to our first survey 4 years in the past, no systematic research of the business had been performed to find out what number of indices there have been.

Our first survey was eye-opening: It revealed that our members administer roughly three million indices. This ubiquity speaks to the utility of indices for measuring markets, benchmarking, efficiency attribution, danger analytics, and typically offering a universe for funding composition. Many buyers solely consider the funding merchandise based mostly on the indices, when the truth is indices have a much wider scope and a variety of use circumstances.

As we started compiling this yr’s knowledge, we knew instantly that the outcomes had been compelling. They replicate an business on the innovative, investing in analysis, knowledge, and operational capabilities. As a result of regulatory and capital modifications pushed by the Nice Recession, lots of the analysis features beforehand carried out by The Avenue at the moment are being performed by index suppliers.

Tile for SBBI Summary Edition

ESG nets document progress.

Essentially the most shocking results of this yr’s survey? The unprecedented progress in ESG indices. To name this a development could be an understatement: It’s a paradigm shift. The variety of indices measuring ESG standards grew by greater than 40% prior to now yr. This represents the biggest single year-on-year enhance amongst any single main index kind in our survey’s historical past.

Whereas a big bounce, it perhaps shouldn’t come as such a shock given ESG investing’s increasing reputation. New laws, significantly in Europe, growing environmental issues throughout the globe, and long-term socio-economic and demographic modifications have all propelled buyers towards sustainable methods.

ESG efficiency hasn’t harm both: In periods of peak pandemic volatility during the last yr, ESG proved its mettle and outperformed in lots of markets. Analysis reviews on ESG firms have proven many “asset gentle” corporations have accomplished very nicely all through the pandemic.

To make certain, extra work is required to enhance the standard of ESG knowledge. Comparable emission knowledge, for instance, amongst different inputs, are essential to make apples-to-apples comparisons. Nonetheless, the information will proceed to enhance and indices will proceed to turn into extra exact. And buyers ought to ultimately coalesce round widespread ESG definitions to replicate their social preferences.

Massive institutional funds have began to embrace extra ESG-friendly mandates, driving giant asset flows into the house. And this rising focus among the many institutional section has unfold to retail buyers. Index suppliers have responded to elevated demand for ESG indices by growing extra product and methodology improvements. The outdated days of ESG administration by easy exclusionary screens are over. There at the moment are extra refined ESG factor-based index screening and weighting processes.

Financial Analysts Journal Ad

Mounted revenue will get dynamic.

The fixed-income house has likewise seen expansive progress. Our survey discovered the variety of indices protecting fixed-income markets grew 7.1% prior to now yr and practically 15% during the last two.


Two pie charts showing 2020 Fixed Income Indices Share by Geography and Market Segment

Mounted revenue is usually thought of “tougher to measure” due to the complicated and opaque nature of bond markets. However index suppliers have innovated and developed new indices which have given buyers entry to beforehand unavailable areas of the fixed-income sector

Our survey revealed that the biggest share of fixed-income indices are within the Americas. This isn’t the case for equities. What explains the discrepancy? The variety of the fixed-income markets within the Americas. For instance, the USA has many extra forms of municipal bonds and really intensive securitization markets in comparison with different nations.

Tendencies in Equities

Trade and sector indices account for nearly half of fairness indices, in line with our survey, and there’s motion in direction of extra international indices. In 2020 there was a decline in cap-weighted indices relative to such newer areas as ESG and thematic indices. That the Americas have such a small share of fairness indices might come as a shock to some, however Europe, the Center East, and Asia have many nations with their very own inventory markets driving the outcomes. Our survey additionally exhibits a rising share of rising and frontier fairness markets indices.


Charts of 2020 Equities Indices Shares by Geography and Market Segment

A Revealing 12 months

Whereas ESG and stuck revenue skilled probably the most improvement and funding within the index business in 2020, in addition they replicate a broader shift. The index business has seen extra innovation within the final decade than in any of the 13 previous it. As investor wants have grown and advanced, the index business has had do adapt to maintain tempo.

New contributors proceed to enter a aggressive house. ETFGI, an ETF business consulting and analysis agency, follows 255 index suppliers, whereas Morningstar has 199 index suppliers of their database. There isn’t any scarcity of corporations making an attempt to provide you with new and “higher” concepts. ETFGI not too long ago reported that after accelerating progress in recent times, international property invested in index-based ETFs and ETPs surpassed US$7 trillion on the finish of August.

So what has fueled this progress? Price discount is the prime wrongdoer and buyers have benefited enormously. The Committee for Financial Improvement (CED), in a 2019 research, estimated the fee financial savings for buyers to be between $12 billion and $15 billion per yr. Add that to the discount in charges throughout all forms of funds and in transactions prices, and the middle estimated value financial savings to be within the vary of $40 billion to $50 billion yearly.

The Future of Investment Management

The yr 2020 has posed an amazing problem for international monetary markets, for the index business, and for the world. Indices had been battle-tested in actual time and index suppliers demonstrated their consistency and preparedness.

Our survey outcomes throw the way forward for the business and the markets into stark aid: This future can be formed by new funding standards, higher informational calls for, and merchandise that extra immediately — and inexpensively — deal with investor wants throughout a wider set of asset courses.

That is the third installment of a sequence from the Index Trade Affiliation (IIA).

When you favored this publish, don’t neglect to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.


All posts are the opinion of the creator. As such, they shouldn’t be construed as funding recommendation, nor do the opinions expressed essentially replicate the views of CFA Institute or the creator’s employer.

Picture credit score: ©Getty Photos / Paolo Carnassale

Rick Redding, CFA

Rick Redding, CFA, is the chief govt officer at Index Trade Affiliation (IIA), the first-ever commerce group for impartial index suppliers globally. Previous to his function with IIA, Redding served as managing director and in varied senior positions guiding product innovation at CME Group.



Supply hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *