The Failure Of Financial Growth In Jamaica - Geo Tv News

The Failure Of Financial Growth In Jamaica


I learn lately that Jamaica is now the 4th most indebted nation on the planet. Additionally, in a speech in 2009 concerning the Jamaican financial system Mr. Bruce Golding (former Prime Minister) stated that Jamaica’s Gross Home Product (whole quantity of products and providers) was J$ 560 billion and that after paying curiosity on money owed there was solely J$70 billion left; hardly sufficient for improvement tasks, capital accumulation or to pay for different obligations. The shortfall has due to this fact to be made up yearly by extra borrowing at very excessive rates of interest with debt piling up on high of debt.

All of this makes one ask how Jamaica bought into this sorry scenario? Who was accountable? Or was it simply inevitable as soon as we had chosen to observe a path to independence on our personal? If we glance again at our historical past for the previous fifty years we’ll see that on the time of independence in 1962 Jamaica made 2 elementary errors which had detrimental penalties. The primary was the secession from the West Indies Federation in 1961 and the second was the coverage of successive governments after independence to industrialize the financial system and neglect agriculture.


Jamaica’s secession from the West Indies Federation was the results of a referendum to determine Jamaica’s future within the Federation in 1961. Bustamante, the Chief of the Opposition who had initially supported the Federation, badly misplaced the Basic election in 1959 and with a brand new set of Deputy Leaders (Tavares, Lightboune- a former federal MP and Seaga) abruptly turned in opposition to the Federation, made a problem out of it and used it to assault the Norman Manley authorities. They launched a marketing campaign in opposition to the Federation arguing to the voters that it was a type of slavery as JLP loudspeaker vehicles bellowed throughout the island with cries of “freedom, freedom”. Manley succumbed, referred to as a referendum and the folks voted in opposition to it. Jamaica withdrew and the Federation ended.

Jamaica’s withdrawal was a grave mistake as a result of Jamaica is simply too small when it comes to geographical and inhabitants dimension and too poor in assets to isolate. The formation of Caricom quickly after the autumn of the Federation testifies to the necessity for some type of union. Caricom was fashioned to supply an financial linkage between the English-speaking nations of the Caribbean. Now we even have a standard legislation faculty and Attraction courtroom (although Jamaica has not but joined the courtroom). A federated Caribbean would have been a stronger regional bloc with huge potential particularly if we might have added Guyana (massive, wealthy in assets and underpopulated), the Bahamas (huge vacationer business) and Bermuda (very excessive per capita revenue). And sure, the French and Dutch West Indies; many various cultures and languages however so too are the nations that comprise the European Financial Group. Federation would have served us effectively, particularly now that regionalism is spreading the world over because it turns into extra obvious that globalization largely advantages the wealthy nations.


The second elementary mistake was made in 1962, the yr of independence. The newly elected JLP authorities led by Bustamante determined to transform Jamaica from an agricultural nation into an industrial one primarily based on a technique of import- substitution manufacturing, tourism and bauxite. The federal government felt that, within the custom of the developed nations, improvement essentially concerned a transition from an agricultural financial system to industrialization. Accordingly, the federal government invited overseas firms to put money into Jamaica with the lure of low cost labor and tax holidays of three to five years. Sir Arthur Lewis referred to as it “industrialization by invitation” (Industrialization of the British West Indies).

Industrialization had restricted success. From the 1960’s direct overseas funding expanded however it solely led to extra dependency on know-how, uncooked supplies and capital from overseas. Moreover, the businesses have been primarily overseas so the income have been despatched overseas. One other drawback was that as quickly because the tax holidays ran out the businesses packed up and left, taking every little thing with them and leaving no skilled personnel behind.

With industrialization, the overseas firms have been working underneath license. Their merchandise have been inferior and uncompetitive as was illustrated by the native made razor blades, sneakers and Good Yr tires within the 1970’s. The Good Yr manufacturing unit in St.Thomas closed in 1997 due to ‘ intense strain from decrease price producers’.

As a substitute of lowering unemployment because it was purported to do, industrialization destroyed jobs. In line with the legislation of ‘economies of scale’, a small producer can’t compete with a big manufacturing unit that mass produces items. So producers in small cottage industries have been changed by the brand new competitors and this led to a flight from the land of the newly displaced employees to the city areas the place they joined the ranks of the unemployed. Unemployment charges particularly among the many youth hovered within the area of 25% between 1975 and 1985. And whereas in 1960 34% of the inhabitants was city, by 1982 it elevated to 48% because of declining alternatives in rural areas (US Library of Congress).


Agriculture is important to the Jamaican financial system as a result of it gives meals, employment and overseas trade surplus for funding in business. Successive governments through the years have uncared for agriculture as they’ve decreased funding in agricultural packages and infrastructure. This neglect was marked by a decline within the agricultural share of GDP within the 1980’s; for instance. from 1980 to 1987 agriculture as a share of GDP dropped from 8.3 % to five.7 % (US Library of Congress).

The decline in agriculture is illustrated by the rise in imported meals which needed to be paid for with important overseas forex and extra borrowing. The lack of agricultural manufacturing resulted in additional city unemployment and crime. A latest Report from the World Financial institution and the UN Workplace of Medicine and Crime states that Jamaica has the best homicide charge on the planet and the Caribbean the best crime charge on the planet.

The autumn of agricultural output and the restricted success of the commercial sector to switch it as an engine of financial progress left a big exterior debt within the 1970’s and 1980’s in order that by the top of 1986 the debt was US$ 3.5 billion, one of many highest per capita money owed on the planet ( US Library of Congress).

The financial failures haven’t been all of the fault of presidency. Exterior elements have had an affect as effectively. The decline of sugar manufacturing since 1965 was as a consequence of mechanization and competitors from beet sugar in Europe. The decreasing of demand for bauxite was as a result of introduction of synthetics in order that by the mid 1980’s bauxite solely comprised 30% of aluminum. The rise in world oil costs helped to create double – digit inflation within the mid 1970’s and the volatility of tourism was partially as a consequence of elevated competitors from different nations.


The primary argument of this paper may be summarized by the next quote: “The messages from the 1960’s are plain. There may be no large industrialization of Jamaica to soak up structural (long run) unemployment. The bauxite business will present capital and export earnings which should be used accurately for labor-intensive improvement. The key of success, if there may be to be success, might be within the countryside – not within the cities… Jamaica must develop into self-sufficient in meals to get rid of meals imports, modernize and rationalize agricultural manufacturing, diversify away from sugar and create over 100,000 jobs on the land or in processing or associated work. Jamaica can’t resolve her ‘inner safety’ drawback with out a mobilization of her assets and, above all, of her folks.” Violence and Politics in Jamaica 1960- 1970, by Terry Lacey.

Tourism, bauxite and sugar are important for employment and as overseas trade earners. And so too are our small cottage industries. However any improvement plan to supply financial progress should give precedence to agriculture as a result of business has not confirmed to be an sufficient substitute as a generator of progress.

It’s by agriculture that Jamaica will have the ability to mobilize its idle land and other people. Firstly, we have to revolutionize our training system i.e. agriculture should be included into the first and secondary faculties’ curricula. Additionally we have to assist agricultural enterprises and supply rewards for his or her successes. To those ends nice use may be made of knowledge know-how such because the Web. Secondly, land and other people may be introduced into productive use by the system of “usufruct”. This dates again to the Emperor Gaius in Historic Rome and is used with nice success at present in some creating nations like Cuba. Persons are given using land; they don’t have to pay for it offered they make productive use of it.

One final level. I believe we have to cease trying North to the richer nations for help. We’ve extra frequent pursuits with our neighbors within the Caribbean and the Americas. We should always attempt to develop nearer regional ties with them.

I hope that my evaluation has helped to reply the questions I posed originally of this paper. Nonetheless, a take a look at our financial historical past raises extra questions on us as a folks than it solutions.

By Victor A. Dixon

November 6, 2011

Supply by Victor A Dixon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *